Top 18 Mature Cheddar Cheeses Products

Get your taste buds tingling with these scrumptious mature cheddar cheeses. Check out our reviews and find out where to get your hands on them.
1

What people say

1,194 reviews from 9 shops
“I love cathedral city cheese an this one didn’t disappoint very tasty an fresh lovely”
“The taste is wonderful I can add to dishes or have a sandwich it is very well priced for a big block great on baked potatoes”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.99
£3.25
+6
STORES
2

What people say

402 reviews from 8 shops
“This is my new favourite cheese love the tangy taste to it the whole family love it its great with a pasta bake and jacket potato well worth the money if you love strong tasting cheese this is the cheese for you”
“Very versatile product tasted great both cold on crackers as well as when fused in cooking”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.99
£3.50
+5
STORES
3

What people say

342 reviews from 7 shops
“These cheese is great it has a strong mature flavour still even though it is a lighter cheese”
“Love how it's a lighter version so you can feel like you're not eating as much fat as the normal version but yet it still tastes the same”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.50
£3.50
+4
STORES
4

What people say

156 reviews from 5 shops
“I love this cheese its not silly strong with an after taste its a smooth tasting cheese with just the right strength”
“I love this the taste is strong and lovely and the texture it's one of my favourite cheeses it's just so expensive for me it's a treat !”

Where to buy

£4.40
£5.19
£5.20
+2
STORES
5
6
7

What people say

162 reviews from 5 shops
“I think that it is about one of the best on the market and certainly has a better texture/flavour than Cathedral which I find greasy to cook with too”
“Love the strong tanginess that you can feel on your tongue after eating”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.85
£3.00
+2
STORES
8

What people say

372 reviews from 6 shops
“This is my usual cheese but I do try other cheeses but alway go back to this one for excellent flavour and as a mature cheese it has just about right”
“This is the nicest cheese in the world and I've tried a lot of cheeses!! The only downside for this amazing cheese is that it is a tad overpriced”

Where to buy

£3.75
£4.50
£4.60
+3
STORES
9

What people say

104 reviews from 1 shop
“This is by far the tastiest Cheddar available in a supermarket own brand product”
“This is my Cathedral City substitute for those times that CC isn't on special”

Where to buy

£3.00
10

What people say

34 reviews from 1 shop
“Very good as a lunchtime snack on a sandwich”
“This is hands down the best tasting cheese”

Where to buy

£2.45