Top 10 Cheddar Cheeses

Discover the UK's favourite cheddar cheeses, see how shoppers rate them, and learn where you can buy them across 15 supermarkets.
1

What people say

411 reviews from 8 shops
“This is my new favourite cheese love the tangy taste to it the whole family love it its great with a pasta bake and jacket potato well worth the money if you love strong tasting cheese this is the cheese for you”
“Very versatile product tasted great both cold on crackers as well as when fused in cooking”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.99
£3.00
+5
STORES
2

What people say

54 reviews from 4 shops
“This is a really strong rich flavour”
“This is a very tasty cheese if you don't want it to burn your tongue”

Where to buy

£2.90
£3.15
£3.50
+1
STORE
3

What people say

159 reviews from 3 shops
“These cheese is nice we used to eat cathedral city light but this is cheaper and compares to the taste too”
“This is creamy and a great flavour”

Where to buy

£2.50
£3.25
£3.25
4

What people say

1,207 reviews from 9 shops
“I love cathedral city cheese an this one didn’t disappoint very tasty an fresh lovely”
“The taste is wonderful I can add to dishes or have a sandwich it is very well priced for a big block great on baked potatoes”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.99
£3.00
+6
STORES
5

What people say

269 reviews from 5 shops
“This is the tastiest extra mature that I have ever tried! For me it is perfect! So glad I tried it!! Highly recommended!”
“This is a great flavoured cheese”

Where to buy

£3.00
£3.00
£3.56
+2
STORES
6

What people say

203 reviews from 7 shops
“Very tasty! Tried it for the first time and was very nicely surprised as it is great on its own and in a sandwich”
“I love this cheese its not silly strong with an after taste its a smooth tasting cheese with just the right strength”

Where to buy

£2.75
£2.85
£3.00
+4
STORES
7

What people say

173 reviews from 4 shops
“This is now my favourite cheddar - great for both cooking and eating with crackers etc”
“I think this tastes better than cathedral even though its still on the pricey side”

Where to buy

£5.19
£5.20
£5.20
+1
STORE
8

What people say

16 reviews from 3 shops
“I love this cheese”
“This is it”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.18
£4.20
9

What people say

19 reviews from 3 shops
“LOVE pilgrims lighter extra mature I'm glad Morrison's finally sell it”
“Love this lighter version”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.00
£4.20
10
11

What people say

121 reviews from 5 shops
“This is the only lactose free cheese that actually tastes like cheese and not flavourless rubber!! It's perfect”
“Very pleased and great for melting on Nachos”

Where to buy

£2.40
£2.60
£2.70
+2
STORES
12

What people say

213 reviews from 4 shops
“These cheese is great it has a strong mature flavour still even though it is a lighter cheese”
“Love how it's a lighter version so you can feel like you're not eating as much fat as the normal version but yet it still tastes the same”

Where to buy

£3.75
£5.00
£5.40
+1
STORE
13

What people say

18 reviews from 4 shops
“This is less fat and tasty”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.00
£3.50
+1
STORE
14

What people say

256 reviews from 6 shops
“I love Cathedral City cheese so having a grated cheese product available is ideal for me”
“This is a tasty handy way to use for many different dishes”

Where to buy

£2.39
£2.40
£2.40
+3
STORES
15

What people say

494 reviews from 6 shops
“I love extra mature cheddar so it would be great if it was available in other versions”
“This is truly a delicious cheddar whether you're interested in lacto free or not!! My husband needs lacto free products and we have been buying the mild (rubbery?) one for some time - I found it too bland personally”

Where to buy

£2.00
£2.50
£2.50
+3
STORES
16

What people say

156 reviews from 7 shops
“This is my usual cheese but I do try other cheeses but alway go back to this one for excellent flavour and as a mature cheese it has just about right”
“I love this tasty cheese and the slices are really handy as well as giving portion control!!”

Where to buy

£2.00
£2.39
£2.40
+4
STORES
17

What people say

201 reviews from 1 shop
“I think this cheese has great flavour which suits the whole family at an equally great price”
“Very good alternative compared to more expensive well known brands”

Where to buy

£4.88
18

What people say

48 reviews from 4 shops
“This is our favourite cheese so tasty I buy both block and grated is so handy when making cheese sauce On offer a lot”
“This is seriously good and you wouldnt know it was 30% lighter!! Melts brilliantly and makes a great ham and cheese toastie! A regular of ours now!!!”

Where to buy

£2.00
£2.39
£2.40
+1
STORE
19

What people say

105 reviews from 1 shop
“This is by far the tastiest Cheddar available in a supermarket own brand product”
“This is my Cathedral City substitute for those times that CC isn't on special”

Where to buy

£3.00
20

What people say

53 reviews from 1 shop
“This is wonderful - far better that D Cornish vintage at Waitrose - but why am I telling you this when it means the stock will run out ? I have been buying this since mid-2019 (I think) when I first saw it on the shelvs at M&S - its just superb & with a long shelf life also”
“This is a lovely multipurpose cheese”

Where to buy

£7.00
Cheeses
Cheddars
Mature Cheeses
Grated Cheeses
Slices
Cheese Slices