Top 10 Custard Tarts

Discover the UK's favourite custard tarts, see how shoppers rate them, and learn where you can buy them across 15 supermarkets.
1

What people say

79 reviews from 1 shop
“very nice egg custard tarts and the pasty is lovely ”
“I love these they are perfect”

Where to buy

£1.00
2

What people say

211 reviews from 1 shop
“Very eggy and creamy with just the right amount of bite to the pastry”
“Very fresh and tasty”

Where to buy

£1.00
3
M&S
Egg Custard Tarts
2 x
Vegetarian

What people say

93 reviews from 1 shop
“These were delicious and the pastry was fresh and not too heavy”
“These are delicious egg custards”

Where to buy

£1.40
4

What people say

187 reviews from 1 shop
“Love these fresh and still good the day after”
“These have the authentic taste and texture of home-made”

Where to buy

£1.25
5
6

What people say

28 reviews from 2 shops
“These tarts are delicious and very suitable for the colder weather”
“These are delicious; Mr Kipling excels himself again”

Where to buy

£1.75
£2.85
7

Where to buy

£0.85
8

What people say

50 reviews from 1 shop
“These half baked tarts are by far way better than the ready fully baked version as unless completely fresh the pastry of the full baked tarts becomes rubbery and without crispness”
“These are absolutely delicious”

Where to buy

£3.00
9

What people say

47 reviews from 1 shop
“These are absolutely delicious! Wouldn't know they were gluten free: pastry holds together perfectly! Flavour great and have become a weekly staple”
“These are as delicious as regular egg custards and completely gluten and wheat free! Please stock more gluten free kitchen 🙏”

Where to buy

£3.90
10

What people say

54 reviews from 1 shop
“These tarts were gorgeous really authentic”
“They are very sweet and tasty”

Where to buy

£4.55
11

What people say

46 reviews from 1 shop
“These are delicious and good quality”
“These are so moreish”

Where to buy

£2.55
12

What people say

157 reviews from 1 shop
“I love egg custards but trying to find a decent one as morrisons are awful so these make a wonderful alternative”
“These are delicious and its so nice having them in the freezer to have as an occasional treat for breakfast and not having to run out to go find some!”

Where to buy

£4.75
13
14

What people say

92 reviews from 1 shop
“These authentic Pastel de Nata are splendid little mouthfuls of a special treat”
“They are perfect when warmed up for a few minutes in the oven to crisp the pastry”

Where to buy

£1.00
15

What people say

140 reviews from 1 shop
“these custard slices are like a real custard slice with vanilla custard in the middle as it should have and not cream”
“These are becoming a special treat for us on a Saturday!”

Where to buy

£2.00
16

What people say

65 reviews from 1 shop
“These are excellent and my favorite confection but the last two times I ordered they are not showing in the llist - I do hope they are not discontinued”
“These are really lovely but”

Where to buy

£1.75
17

What people say

105 reviews from 1 shop
“They are delicious and just the right amount of sugar without being too sweet”
“They are not too sweet either as I find others I have bought have a very sugar sweet topping ”

Where to buy

£1.85
18

What people say

314 reviews from 1 shop
“These are a great stand in for a classic cream slice same vanilla icing & lovely soft custard filling”
“These are very creamy and the pastry was not dry at all! Very sweet and creamy and are packed full of custard! Well presented in the packaging and not smashed up and broken”

Where to buy

£2.25
19

What people say

117 reviews from 1 shop
“Very tasty loved eating them with our family and friends”
“These are a firm favourite in our family”

Where to buy

£2.25
20
Pastries
Custard Slices
Slices
Sweets
Tartlets