Top 14 Extra Mature Cheddar Cheeses Products

Get ready for some seriously delicious cheese – discover the best Extra Mature Cheddars around, with reviews and handy tips on where to buy them.
1

What people say

263 reviews from 8 shops
“This is my new favourite cheese love the tangy taste to it the whole family love it its great with a pasta bake and jacket potato well worth the money if you love strong tasting cheese this is the cheese for you”
“Very versatile product tasted great both cold on crackers as well as when fused in cooking”

Where to buy

£2.99
£2.99
£3.00
+5
STORES
2

What people say

245 reviews from 6 shops
“I love a good strong creamy cheese was definitely not disappointed in this it's perfect with anything pastas on toast with crackers was a massive hit a Christmas with caramalised onion chutney on crackers”
“I love this cheese! Its strong and tangy with the perfect creamy melt in mouth texture”

Where to buy

£4.40
£5.40
£5.40
+3
STORES
3

What people say

139 reviews from 5 shops
“I love it in a toastie with loads of sliced green finger chillies! It tastes better than a lot of "vintage" cheeses do! Getting through a block every week ½ now - oh yes!”
“Very mature tasty cheese that leaves NO bitter after taste behind”

Where to buy

£3.25
£3.75
£4.75
+2
STORES
4

What people say

176 reviews from 4 shops
“This is now my favourite cheddar - great for both cooking and eating with crackers etc”
“I think this tastes better than cathedral even though its still on the pricey side”

Where to buy

£5.19
£5.20
£5.20
+1
STORE
5

What people say

222 reviews from 8 shops
“I think that it is about one of the best on the market and certainly has a better texture/flavour than Cathedral which I find greasy to cook with too”
“Love the strong tanginess that you can feel on your tongue after eating”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.50
£4.19
+5
STORES
6
7

What people say

289 reviews from 5 shops
“This is the tastiest extra mature that I have ever tried! For me it is perfect! So glad I tried it!! Highly recommended!”
“This is a great flavoured cheese”

Where to buy

£4.50
£4.50
£4.50
+2
STORES
8
9

What people say

454 reviews from 1 shop
“I think this is as good as Cathedral City extra mature at much better value”
“very tasty extra mature cheddar and excellent value”

Where to buy

£4.80
10

What people say

50 reviews from 2 shops
“I love this cheese - strong tasting and very creamy”
“This is delightful”

Where to buy

£2.85
£3.50