"This is the second jar we've bought and it is much ore runny (oily?) than the first jar we got"

"This is simply the best peanut butter I've ever tasted! It's both creamy and crunchy"

"Very runny to the point that once I stirred it after it had separated (loads of oil on top when I opened it up)"

"This is my fave peanut butter and it has awesome crunchy bits"